​

TROY- (WRGB) The city of Troy is encouraging residents to donate to local nonprofits supporting the homeless instead of giving money to panhandlers. The city has installed around 20 signs, costing approximately $500, to promote this initiative. However, the signs have faced criticism, with some claiming they further criminalize homelessness. One sign was even altered to read “It’s okay to panhandle.”

Mayor Carmella Mantello acknowledged that the signs alone won’t deter panhandling but are part of a broader strategy. “It’s all part of enforcement,” she said, emphasizing the importance of directing people to say no to panhandlers and donate to the 40-plus nonprofits in the area.

Despite the initiative, Joseph’s House and Shelter Executive Director Amy LaFountain reported no increase in individual donations. “We have not seen any like increase in individual giving,” she said, noting that larger signs were only recently installed. However, LaFountain believes the signs have sparked important conversations about homelessness in the city.

Mayor Mantello stated that the city is committed to addressing panhandling and homelessness. “We do have zero tolerance. We’re not going to accept it here in Troy,” she said, adding that the city will continue tackling these issues around the clock. While the city is not arresting panhandlers unless they obstruct traffic, police have the authority to arrest and fine them in such cases. Additionally, the city is working to remove stairs from abandoned buildings to prevent people from attempting to live in them.